It’s bad enough that every thing we do in the world today is sucked up by some fecking AI and turned into training data. That means we are working for free. They are getting something from us. What are we getting from them?
We are getting a new, international underclass:
AI’s development so far has been based on the exploitation of workers and users around the world,[1] performing what anthropologist Mary L. Gray and computational social scientist Siddharth Suri call ghost work.[2] This term refers to the undervalued human labor utilized to develop and maintain the automation of websites and apps. Ghost work is characterized by on-demand, short-term projects or tasks performed globally by precarized workers through platforms like Amazon Mechanical Turk and specialized companies like Sama.
When the average American thinks of the AI industry he or she probably imagines nerds and techies in Silicon Valley. But those folks are like the managers in a hotel. It takes an army of maids and other grunt-level people to actually make the hotel work. The manager sits on top of a big heap of helpers.
These workers, usually vulnerable people from Asia, Latin America, and Africa, are paid less than $2 per hour to generate and label data that trains AI models. Moreover, users who validate algorithmic outputs or help perfect systems usually do it for free. ¬Ghost work is often outsourced, hidden, or rendered invisible by the tech companies who request it. As Noopur Raval argues, we must ask ourselves how and for whom this work is invisible and what happens when workers are finally seen.[3]
It’s pretty obvious that the people in charge of these AI companies are a bunch of assholes. And I’m not just looking at Jensen Huang. (Mark Zuckerberg looks pretty stupid in a leather jacket, too.) The rich hate to pay for anything, especially labor. They’ll squeeze a goddamn nickel out of every breath a worker takes. These people depend on a permanent army of poor people to do the dirty work so they can get filthy rich.
Speaking of filthy rich, Anthropic wants a trillion dollars. That’s one hell of a long con.

***The quoted material above is from “Data Work and its Layers of (In)visibility” by Adrienne Williams and Milagros Miceli on the Social Science Research Council website Just Tech. You can find the footnoted references there.